Home > Gentlemens Grooming > Shaving Creams and Shaving Soaps > Captain's Choice

Founded in June 2011, Captain's Choice was born out of The Captain not being able to find an aftershave he liked, so he made his own. All of the Captain's soaps, and even the lather bowls are proudly handcrafted in the USA! Also, Captain's Choice is a proud supporter of the Midwest Shelter for Homeless Veterans (MSHV). Founded in 2007, MSHV operates on a vision of No Hero Left Behind due to homelessness, joblessness, poverty and/or mental-health issues. Visit their website for more information on this worthy cause!

Midwest Shelter for Homeless Veterans
Sort By:
Page of 1
Captain's Choice Bay Rum Shaving Soap Captain's Choice Bay Rum Shaving Soap


An amazing, pure Bay Rum scent that is sure to remind you of the old days on the high seas...

Proudly made in America!


OUR PRICE: $14.95
Captain's Choice North Shaving Soap Captain's Choice North Shaving Soap


An exhilarating evergreen scent, enhanced with juniper and vanilla to revitalize your morning routine.


Proudly made in America!

OUR PRICE: $14.95
Captain's Choice Sandalwood Shaving Soap Captain's Choice Sandalwood Shaving Soap


Captain's Choice Sandalwood - Packed with the manly fragrance of earthy sandalwood!

Proudly made in America!


OUR PRICE: $14.95
Captain's Choice Lime Shaving Soap Captain's Choice Lime Shaving Soap


Captain's Choice Lime- A refreshing, bright citrus scent delivering the wonderful aroma of fresh lime!

Proudly made in America!


OUR PRICE: $14.95
Captain's Choice 45th Parallel Shaving Soap Captain's Choice 45th Parallel Shaving Soap


Captain's Choice 45th Parallel - An amazing cherry scented soap with the great performance of Captains Choice shaving soap!

Proudly made in America!

OUR PRICE: $14.95
Captain's Choice Ceramic Lather Bowl - Rawhide (color) Captain's Choice Ceramic Lather Bowl - Rawhide (color)


Handcrafted by a local (to the Captain) potter and created according to the Captain's exact specifications, each lather bowl features ridges on the bottom to expedite the lathering process.

Proudly made in America!

OUR PRICE: $30.00